Third-Party Cookies vs First-Party Cookies
Executive Summary and Article NavigationDiscussion and definitions of:
- What is a cookie
- The difference between 1st-party and 3rd-party cookies
- Rejection of 3rd-party cookies
- Effects of blocking / deleting cookies
Who wants a cookie?What are cookies? Here are a few over-lapping definitions;
What is a (third-party) cookie?
A cookie is a small bit of text placed on the hard drive of your computer by the server of a website that you visit. The cookie is placed there for the purpose of recognizing your specific browser or remembering information specific to your browser, were you to return to the same site.
All cookies have an owner which tells you who the cookie belongs to. The owner is the domain specified in the cookie.
In “third-party cookie”, the word “party” refers to the domain as specified in the cookie; the website that is placing the cookie. So, for example, if you visit widgets.com and the domain of the cookie placed on your computer is widgets.com, then this is a first-party cookie. If, however, you visit widgets.com and the cookie placed on your computer says stats-for-free.com, then this is a third-party cookie.
Opentracker provides services that allow the companies and websites to track their visitors with first-party cookies.
Reports and research on the subject of website tracking tell us that the rejection of third-party cookies is growing. Increasing numbers of people are either manually blocking third-party cookies, or deleting them regularly.
That is why Opentracker utilizes 1st party cookie technology.
The cookies being deleted / blocked are third-party party cookies, as opposed to less problematic first-party cookies.
How many people or software tools delete third party cookies? The numbers given can be as high as 40%. If you count that many anti-spyware applications and default privacy settings also block 3rd party cookies, then it is possible that a high percentage of cookies are being blocked.
Blocking and deleting cookies
Why do far fewer people block first-party cookies? It is estimated that a very low percentage of people block first party cookies, less than 5%. The reason for this is primarily that it is very difficult to surf the internet without accepting these cookies. First party cookies are necessary in order for you to be recognised as an individual. Any site that you login to as an individual requires a way of identifying you as “you”. Hotmail, Yahoo, Gmail, online banking, ebay, Amazon, etc.
Additionally, anti-spyware software and privacy settings do not target first-party cookies.
We use first party cookies as our first line of analysis, and ip number with user agent as the secondary line. AOL users are identified more specifically because their ip number changes with every click.
What actually happens when cookies are blocked / rejected?
1st party cookies: it is very hard to login anywhere
3rd party cookies: no adverse effects to surfing
Q: How does this affect tracking systems, when people block / delete cookies?
A: All visits will still be recorded, but a person who has deleted the cookies will not be recognised as the same (returning) visitor.
When cookies are in place, and not blocked or deleted, total visitor counts will remain comparatively low. If a person constantly deletes cookies, they will be counted as a new “unique” visitor with every subsequent visit.
In response to these trends, the first step is to find out if the statistics that you collect utilise first-party or third-party cookies. Ask your statistics or tracking company. Asking questions usually leads to more questions, always a good thing when it comes to gathering and analysing data.